Oregon Indian War Claims Interviews

Two of my Mulkey ancestors were interviewed by the Oregon Indian War Claims Commission in 1859. The commission was charged with auditing claims arising from the Rogue River war in Oregon in 1855-56.

John Thomas Mulkey, my third-great-grandfather, was called an “Indian war veteran” in his 1896 death notice:

DIED — Wednesday August 26, 1896, at the insane asylum, Thomas Mulkey. The deceased was the eldest son of the late Elder Phillip Mulkey; was born in Kentucky in the year 1825, and leaves eight grown sons and daughters. He was an Indian war veteran. He was buried in the Mulkey cemetery near Eugene Thursday afternoon.1

Ever since I first came across this information, I have wanted to learn more about how he came to be in Oregon, and about his military service in particular. This post represents my first attempt at documenting his journey against the larger backdrop of the early history of Oregon.

* * *

The United States and Great Britain had competing claims on the North American continent west of the Rocky Mountains that were decided in 1846 with an “amicable compromise” called the “Oregon Treaty”, also known as the Buchanan-Pakenham treaty (9 Stat. 869)2. Lands south of the 49th parallel would be controlled by the United States, while lands north of the boundary line would be under British control.3

1850 Map of the state of California, the territories of Oregon & Utah, and the chief part of New Mexico
The Oregon Territory in 1850 included all of modern day Oregon and Washington states, plus parts of Idaho and Wyoming. Washington Territory was carved from the northern Oregon Territory in 1853.

Settlers began pouring into the Oregon Territory in response to new legislation in 1850 that finally fulfilled the promise of free land for white persons and “half-breed Indians” (by definition, Indians with European-American blood) who were at least 18 years of age and citizens of the United States, or who had declared their intention to become citizens.4 Single men could claim up to 320 acres, while the allotment for married men was doubled, with half of the acreage of a married couple designated specifically in the wife’s name.5 Settlers must have arrived in the territory prior to 01 Dec 1850 and have fulfilled certain residency and cultivation requirements.6

The Oregon Donation Land Act was extended twice more before expiration in 1855, albeit with awards of lesser acreage for later arrivals, and a few other changes to the requirements.7 In all, more than 7,400 claims were issued, transferring 2.5 million acres from the Federal government to private hands.8

This 1851 news account sheds some light on the tremendous population surge into the Territory:

The Census of Oregon.—We learn from the Spectator that the report of the Assistant Marshall, Daniel O’Neil, makes out the census to amount to 13,323. It is estimated says the Spectator that there are about 2,000 of the last immigration not included in the above. If that is the case, which we think very probable, our real census amounts to over 15,000 and will no doubt be swelled to 20,000 by the immigration this fall.—Western Star.9

In addition to the lure of rich farmland, miners and prospectors flooded the Umpqua and Rogue river valleys in southwest Oregon Territory seeking a more immediate payoff – gold. Miners on the way to and from the gold fields of California also passed through southern Oregon.

All of these actions created tensions as whites encroached on land long inhabited by indigenous peoples from different tribes and bands. Conflict was perhaps inevitable due to the competition for resources and differing customs and cultures. Indeed the early history of the Oregon Territory was marked by a series of treaties with various tribes and betrayals of those treaties, punctuated by bursts of violence.

Skirmishes, depredations and murder gave way to all out war in the Rogue River valley in 1853 and again in 1855. The United States regular troops in the area were insufficient to quash the increasing levels of violence. In October 1855 Territorial Governor George L. Curry issued a proclamation calling for the creation of a total of nine companies of mounted volunteers: “Each volunteer to furnish his own horse, arms and equipments…and thereafter proceed with the utmost possible despatch to the rendezvous….10

A similar request for volunteers was made the same month by Washington Territorial officials to address their own Indian hostilities, “calling upon the people of the territory capable of bearing arms…”11 Later, Washington Territorial Governor Isaac Stevens, in a speech before Congress, stated “…it is now generally admitted that there was a war raging in Oregon and Washington, and that that war spread from the forty-second to the forty-ninth parallel, and from the shores of the Pacific to a great distance in the interior.”12

The Rogue River War concluded late in the spring of 1856 by peace treaties with the remaining tribes that resulted in a surrender of their arms and agreement to removal to reservations in the area and habitation thereon.

Not long after the close of the war, those who had volunteered as citizen soldiers sought payment, and those who had lost their homes, livestock and other property sought reparations from the Federal government.

“The citizens of Oregon and Washington call upon Congress to make immediate provision for the payment of their claims, as adjusted by law, for expenses incurred in the years 1855 and 1856, in repelling Indian hostilities.”13

A three-man commission comprised of military officers and based in the Oregon Territory was established by Congress to evaluate claims of the volunteer soldiers.14 The commission sought information as to prices of stores, provisions, subsistence and forage at the time of the outbreak of hostilities, and so interviewed citizens to obtain this information. Two of my Mulkey ancestors, Philip Mulkey and his son, John Thomas Mulkey, were among those interviewed. Each statement contains a bit of biographical information besides the facts solicited by the commission which helps paint a more complete picture of the lives and the activities of my ancestors on the frontier.

Statement of J.T. Mulkey.

  Came to Oregon in 1852 ; have since resided in Lane county ; was a private in the volunteer service in the Indian war of 1855 – ’56 ; was in five or six engagements with the Indians ; deemed the war to be just, and absolutely necessary for the protection of the lives of citizens and their property from destruction by the Indians. The ruling cash prices for good American horses during the continuance of the war was from $200 to $300 ; mules from $150 to $250 ; good Indian, Spanish and half-breed horses, suitable for the service, for from $75 to $150 ; good wagons worth from $200 to $300 ; common labor was worth $2 per day ; horse hire, from $2 to $2 50 per day ; oats sold for $1 to $1 25 per bushel ; flour, $3 50 per hundred pounds ; money loaned at 20 and 25 per cent. per annum. Think the property furnished to carry on the war was necessary, and that it was done by the people in good faith.

……his
J. T. x  MULKEY.
……mark

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 19th day of August, 1859.
R.H. PARSONS.
Justice of the Peace. 15

Statement of Philip Mulkey.

  I have resided in Oregon since 1853 ; am a resident of Lane county and a farmer by occupation. Good American horses were worth, during the time of the war, from $200 to $400. Mixed breeds, Spanish and Indian, from $100 to $200, cash value in both cases. Mules were rated from $400 to $600 per pair, cash. Good work oxen, from $150 to $200 per yoke, cash. I turned one good horse into the service ; should have been glad to have received him back at the close of the war at the same I put him in at. Good wagons were worth from $200 to $250. Common laborer’s wages, from $2 50 to $3 per day. Oats worth from $1 to $2 per bushel. Good rifle guns, from $35 to $55. Colt’s revolvers, from $40 to $50. Money loaned from 20 to 36 per cent, per annum. Beef worth $10 per cwt. on foot ; retailed from 15 to 20 cents per pound. My son sold a portion of his scrip for fifty cents on the dollar. He was forced to do so to obtain money. Horse hire was from $2 50 to $3 per day. I turned in my property in good faith, supposing the contract to be as good as any I ever made. The war was just and unavoidable.

PHILIP MULKEY.

STATE OF OREGON, and County of Lane:
Philip Mulkey, being duly sworn, says the within statement is true to the best of his knowledge, information and belief.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 20th day of August, 1859.
R. H. Parsons,
Justice of the Peace 16

Despite repeated Congressional appeals and exhortations in the press, claims arising out of the Rogue River War of 1855-1856 went unreimbursed for years while various constituencies wrangled over the details. When claims were paid out, often the claimants received only one-third of the amount approved by the Commission.17 The final appropriations for payment of soldiers occurred in 1905, nearly half a century after the events originally unfolded.18 Citizens who lost their homes, farms, livestock and other property did not fare much better, as they were not compensated for losses until after the passage of the Indian Depredation Claims Act of 1890.19


Sources and credits:
Image: Map of the state of California, the territories of Oregon & Utah, and the chief part of New Mexico (PhiladelphiaThomas, Cowperthwait & Co., 1850); digital image, David Rumsey Historical Map Collection (http://www.davidrumsey.com/ : accessed 15 Apr 2016).

1 Find A Grave, online database (http://www.findagrave.com : accessed 15 Apr 2016), Thomas Mulkey, memorial no. 84834723, Mulkey Cemetery (Eugene, Lane County, Oregon), citing newspaper death notice published in The Times (Junction City, Oregon) 29 Aug 1896.
2  “Treaty with Great Britain, in Regard to Limits Westward of the Rocky Mountains.”  9 Stat. 869 (1846), digital images, “A Century of Lawmaking for a New Nation: U.S. Congressional Documents and Debates, 1774-1875,” Library of Congress, American Memory (http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/amlaw/ : accessed 24 Apr 2016).
3  ibid.
4 “An Act to create the Office of Surveyor General of the Public Lands in Oregon, and to Provide for the Survey, and to make Donations to Settlers of the Said Public Lands.” 9 Stat 496 (1850), digital images, “A Century of Lawmaking for a New Nation: U.S. Congressional Documents and Debates, 1774-1875,” Library of Congress, American Memory (http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/amlaw/ : accessed 24 Apr 2016).
5 ibid, section 4.
6 ibid.
7 “Amendments to the Donation Law.,” The Columbian (Olympia, Oregon Territory), p. 1, col. 4 ; digital image, Washington State Library website (http://www.sos.wa.gov/library/newspapers_wsl.aspx : accessed 01 May 2016).
8 Oregon State Archives, “A New Territory and the California Gold Rush,” Crafting the Oregon Constitution: Framework for a New State (2009)(http://arcweb.sos.state.or.us/pages/exhibits/1857/before/new.htm : accessed 29 Apr 2016).
9 “The Census of Oregon,” The Oregonian (Portland, O.T.) 19 Apr 1851, p. 2, col. 2.
10 “By the Governor of the Territory of Oregon. A Proclamation.,” Oregon Argus (Oregon City, O.T.) 20 Oct 1855, p. 3, col. 1 ; digital image, Historic Oregon Newspapers (http://oregonnews.uoregon.edu), accessed 29 Apr 2016.
11 “Call for Volunteers.,” Puget Sound Courier (Steilacoom, W.T.) 19 Oct 1855, p. 1, col. 4 ; digital image, Newspapers – Moments in History, Washington State Library (https://www.sos.wa.gov/library/newspapers-moments-in-history.aspx#7), accessed 29 Apr 2016.
12 Isaac I. Stevens, Speech of Hon. Isaac I. Stevens, of Washington Territory, on the Indian war expenses of Washington and Oregon (Washington, D.C. : Lemuel Towers, 1859), p. 3 ; digital images, Internet Archive (https://archive.org : accessed 15 Apr 2016).
13 “Statement of the Oregon and Washington Delegation in Relation to the War Claims of Oregon and Washington,” Pioneer and Democrat (Olympia, W. T.) 27 Apr 1860, p. 1 ; digital images, Washington State Library (http://washington.veridiansoftware.com/ : accessed 29 Apr 2016).
14 ibid.
15 “Report of the Third Auditor of the Treasury in Pursuance of a Resolution of the House of Representatives Passed February 8, 1859.” Ex. Doc. No. 11, 36th Congress, 1st session, p. 98.
16 ibid., p. 99.
17 F. G. Young, “Financial History of Oregon. Part Two. Finances of the Territorial Period, 1849-1859,” Oregon Historical Society Quarterly, vol. 8, no. 2 (Jun 1907) ; JSTOR (http://www.jstor.org/stable/20609727 : accessed 01 May 2016), pp. 187, 189.
18 ibid, p. 190.
19 Oregon Secretary of State, “Oregon History: Indian Wars”, Oregon Blue Book (http://bluebook.state.or.us/cultural/history/history14.htm : accessed 01 May 2016).

“Happiest when surrounded by little children”

1944 newspaper obituary clipping for Anna Mary (Hopkins) Carson of New Jersey and Kansas

1-happiest-obit-carson

[Transcription follows]

[M]ORRIS COUNTY, KANSAS, THURSD[AY]

OBITUARY–CARSON
_____

     Mrs. Andrew Carson, (Anna Mary Hopkins) was born December 25, 1857 in Trenton, N.J., and died at the home of her daughter, Mrs R. Knott in Abilene, Kansas, on Saturday, September 16, 1944, at the age of 86 years, 8 months and 19 days.

     On June 9, 1875 she was united in marriage to Andrew Carson of Trenton, N. J., in 1882 Mr. and Mrs. Carson moved to Skiddy, Kansas, later they moved to a farm near White City, where they lived until 1919 when they moved into town.

     She joined the Methodist church in White City on December 2nd, 1894, during the pastorate of Rev. J. S. Ford. She was a very faithful and active member until her health failed her. By such women of love and integrity are our churches and communities maintained. She was a good neighbor and loved by all who knew her. She was happiest when surrounded by little children.

     Mrs. Carson greatly loved her home and family, always kind and thoughtful as a wife and mother, she lived in her own gentle way.

     Her passing is a great loss, not only to her family but to all who knew her. A devout christian has gone to her God.

     Mr. Carson preceded her in death on April 18, 1937.

     She is survived by the following children: Mrs. Ralph Knott of Abilene, Mrs. George Tyson of Council Grove, Roy of White City, Elmer of Herington, Mrs. Amanda Carroll of Pittsburg, Frank and Raymond Carson and Mrs. Lillian Bailey of Wichita; thirty two grandchildren, eleven great grandchildren and one great, great, grandchild.

     Mrs. Carson had been an invalid for nearly three years, spending most of her time with her daughter Mrs. Knott, who employed Mrs. Cordelia Williams to care for her. About two years ago she fell and broke her hip, and spent some time in the hospital. When it had almost healed several months ago, she had another fall and the hip was rebroken.

     Funeral services were held at the Methodist church Wednesday at 2:30 with interment in White City cemetery. Frey funeral home had charge of arrangements; Rev. O. J. McCulloh preached the sermon.

     The pall bearers were: R. R. Adam, W. H. Ashe, Howard Shepherd, C. C. Miller, George Hauserman and F. F. Girtch.

     Music was furnished by Mrs. J. F. Bacon at the piano and C. C. Miller, Howard Shepherd, Mrs. E. G. Larson, and Mrs J E Bowert, who sang “The Old Rugged Cross,” “Sometime We’ll Understand,” and “Beautiful Isle of Somewhere.”

     Supper was served by the Eastern Star at the Full Plate Cafe to relatives from a distance attending the funeral.

[End of transcription.]
___

I am a descendant of one of the eleven great-grandchildren mentioned in the above obituary. My grandmother would have been one of the unnamed 32 grandchildren, and would probably have attended the funeral of her grandmother, although I do not have any recollection of her telling me that. Our branch of the family has no photographs, letters or ephemera from the New Jersey Hopkins side of the family, and I am still working to prove her ancestry.

The clipping transcribed above is, just that, a clipping, so full publication data for a proper citation is lacking. Two facts suggest publication information: 1) the newspaper was published on a Thursday following the death and funeral of Anna Mary (Hopkins) Carson and, 2) the newspaper was published in Morris County, Kansas.

Consulting a perpetual calendar for 1944, I was able to determine that the likeliest publication date would have been Thursday, 21 Sep 1944, the first Thursday following her death on Saturday, 16 Sep 1944.

I was then able to narrow down the newspaper to one of two possibilities using the U.S. Newspaper Directory, 1690-Present online as part of the Chronicling America project of the Library of Congress, which I have blogged about previously.

2-happiest-us-newspaper-directory
Search of the U.S. Newspaper Directory using state of Kansas, and county of Morris, plus decade from 1940-1950, as shown in yellow, above.

3-happiest-us-newspaper-directory-search-results

Only the Council Grove Republican and White City Register (indicated in red, above) are likely candidates for this newspaper clipping based on the publication information. My belief is this obituary appeared in the 21 Sep 1944 edition of the White City Register, page unknown. Determining whether this is, in fact, true has been added to my “to do” list.


Notes: The formatting shown in this post is not true to the original; it was a very long, narrow column in the original newspaper, which I have chosen not to replicate. In the original, each new section is indented, and there is no spacing between the paragraphs. I was unable to get it properly formatted in this blog post but felt that sharing the information was more important than formatting of same.

1. The children of Anna Mary (Hopkins) Carson all lived in towns and cities in Kansas, although that may not be clear to those unfamiliar with the area.

2. “Mrs. Lillian Bailey of Wichita” was actually Mrs. Lillian Barley, wife of Christian Arthur Barley. They lived in at 850 Faulkner in Wichita in 1943, per Polk’s Wichita City Directory (Kansas City, Missouri: R. L. Polk & Co., 1943), p. 57, entry for Christian A. and Lillian Barley; digital image, “U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989”, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 16 Mar 2014). The 1944 Wichita directory, if one exists, is not available on Ancestry currently.